The National Catholic Review

Over the last few years, I have conducted something of an unplanned survey on parish life around the country. Since 2006 I have visited around 50 parishes—mainly in New York, Connecticut, New Jersey and Pennsylvania—but also in Maryland, Massachusetts, California and Illinois. So let me share some good news from my entirely unscientific survey.

The occasions for these visits are invitations to speak at parishes, usually in the evening, on a topic like the saints or joy in the spiritual life. Normally the schedule proceeds as follows: I am picked up at a train station by the pastor, driven to the rectory, where I dine with the resident priests (sometimes with deacons, sisters or pastoral associates) and shown around the church before the talk. Afterward the pastor or a parishioner drives me back to the station. In the process, everyone is eager to talk about what is going on in their parish.

Mind you, these data are rather random, and I do not aspire to the sociological standards of the Center for Applied Research on the Apostolate. Nonetheless, here is what I’ve learned (no confidences will be broken).

1. Pastors are astonishingly busy. Nor-mally, it is the frazzled pastor, with his clerical collar askew, who meets me at the train station. “Sorry I’m late,” he’ll say. “It’s been a crazy day!” Now everyone seems busy these days, especially parents of young children and those working multiple jobs, but I wonder how many Catholics know how hard their pastors work. In between the sacramental services there is balancing the books, managing the school, visiting the sick and lonely, counseling and on and on. Typically, the pastor works with a small clerical staff. So the first finding: the hard-working, dog-tired pastor is the norm.

2. Sisters and lay pastoral associates are the lifeblood of the church. Last year I spoke at the jubilee Mass of a woman religious. When I arrived, I was deluged with stories about how much people loved her and with detailed descriptions of the dazzling array of activities she had founded. Even sisters in their 70s and 80s who have had several careers are full of zeal for the people of God. One night, following news about the Vatican’s apostolic visitation of American women religious, I met a sister who ran the parish adult initiation program, oversaw other adult education activities and saw a dozen people for spiritual direction. I thought, I wish the Vatican could meet her!

Working just as hard—and taking care of a family on top of it—are lay pastoral associates, who are usually highly educated and experienced but low paid. Without these two groups, sisters and lay associates, our church would grind to a halt.

3. People love their parishes. Before these lectures, I am usually guided through the church. It is always fascinating to take in the architecture (neo-Gothic 1900s, Art Deco 1930s, A-frame 1950s, airy 1980s), examine the statues of the saints and hear the pastor explain any mysterious stained-glass window images. And no matter what the diocese, the easiest conversation starter is, “You have a lovely church.” The response is invariably, “Oh, we love it here!” Then comes the best part of the evening: They tell me how much they treasure their parish, pastor, deacons, sisters and pastoral staff. Most Catholics just love, love, love their parish.

True, not all is well in Catholic Land. I also hear tales of rigid priests and grumpy sisters. And believe me, when people know you are not part of the local diocese and are not going to report them to anyone, the floodgates of complaint open up. But overall, the life of the Catholic parish is flourishing, and I have seen the proof.

James Martin, S.J. is culture editor of America.


Paul Leddy | 10/12/2009 - 4:03pm
Thank you for your observations.  Personally, I don't really know what a typical day is for a parishes' pastor.  I imagine he gets pulled in all different directions; and parishioners must think their pastor has a photographic memory and instant recall. But, if those pastors picking you up at the train station had only asked someone of their parish to pick you up, instead, I'm sure there would have been a stampede of volunteeers wanting to help... if only he would let them.  And, its one thing to pray for vocations to the diaconate; its another thing to encourage and accept vocations to the diaconate. The purpose of the diaconate is to assist priests so that they aren't overburdened, frazzled and harried.  One of the most beautiful things in the world to see is a happy, hearty, loving priest leading his parishioners in the sign of the cross at the beginning of Mass in their own church. I agree with you whole-heartedly: parishioners love, love love their parish and their priests.
2224421 | 10/9/2009 - 10:30pm
A well-deserved acknowledgement of the wonderful staffs who do double and triple duty.  Thank you.  I'm going to share this with my pastor, okay?
2224421 | 10/9/2009 - 10:30pm
A well-deserved acknowledgement of the wonderful staffs who do double and triple duty.  Thank you.  I'm going to share this with my pastor, okay?
2224421 | 10/9/2009 - 10:30pm
A well-deserved acknowledgement of the wonderful staffs who do double and triple duty.  Thank you.  I'm going to share this with my pastor, okay?
2224421 | 10/9/2009 - 10:30pm
A well-deserved acknowledgement of the wonderful staffs who do double and triple duty.  Thank you.  I'm going to share this with my pastor, okay?
Todd Phillipe | 10/9/2009 - 4:47pm
Fr. Jim's points are true, true - and true.  In spite of all the problems the institutional church has, people do love their own pastor and their own parish, and that's why the future of the church is strong and bright, even as dark clouds hang over it.  The laity realizes, and is quick to point out, that the heart of the church is Jesus, and His people on the parish level.  That's where we encounter the living Jesus in a myriad of ways.  I think in the coming decades, church will be more driven from the bottom up, and that's a good thing. 
JUAN JARAMILLO M D MR | 10/9/2009 - 4:35pm
I enjoyed your article very much, Fr. Martin. As a busy catholic-physician-single-father of 2 (teenage boys !), I would say your article is right on the money. I have seen how busy our Prists are, how essential the laity is and yes, I do love my Parish. But actually, I really did not know they were that busy-your article made me feel like going to my Priest and telling him 2 things:  "Thank you !" and "How can I help you ?". I think I'll do just that.
Ivan Hall | 10/9/2009 - 4:30pm
Dear Fr. James.....Your depiction is very accurate. Our Pastor MSGR Paul Enke is extremely busy as he is the only Priest assigned to ST. Edwards. Our Parish has over 1000 families! He is busy every single day. MSGR Enke does a wonderful job and is the main reason our Parish is so wonderful. Our Catholic faith is alive and well.
Ivan Hall

Recently by James Martin, SJ

Jesus Visits Town, Trailing Controversy (September 4, 2016)
Reflections on Pride (June 24, 2016)
Pope to Visit Jesuit Parish in Nairobi (November 25, 2015)
Dom Christian's Testament (November 14, 2015)
Theology and Hate (October 28, 2015)

Recently in Of Many Things