Loading...
Loading...
Click here if you don’t see subscription options
James T. KeaneApril 26, 2009

From today's Los Angeles Times, a story about a college student who has taped Planned Parenthood employees in various states suggesting she lie about her or her boyfriend's age after she posed as a 13-year-old seeking an abortion.

Journalists might note the absurd linguistic hoops the Times copy editors are willing to leap through in order to avoid the term "pro-life," preferring "anti-abortion" or the hardly neutral "abortion foe" (one wonders: where is the abortion fan?).  Reading this story reminded me of the 2004 review in the Times of a Richard Strauss opera in which reviewer Mard Swed's description of "Die Frau Ohne Schatten" was changed without his knowledge from a "glorious and goofy pro-life paean" to a "glorious and goofy anti-abortion paean" at the copy desk. (Read it here).  Swed, of course, meant "life-affirming," but the rules are the rules.  The Times later apologized twice, once for the error and then again for suggesting in their original apology that Swed was the source of the gaffe.

Jim Keane, S.J.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
15 years 12 months ago
It comes as no surprise the L.A. Times will not use the term "pro-life." They are who they are. But if the pro-life community uses the term "pro-abortion," the pro-choice community is up in arms with their nuanced explanation.
15 years 12 months ago
I find it interesting that the LA Times won't use ''pro-life,'' being that it was this paper that exposed the pro-choice bias in reporting on abortion throughout major papers in an enterprising investigative report back in 1990. (http://www.latimes.com/news/obituaries/la-me-shaw01jul01,1,7379263.story?coll=la-news-obituaries)
15 years 12 months ago
"Where is the abortion fan"? Wonder no longer, try George Tiller for starters.
15 years 12 months ago
Dr. Bernard Nathanson, co-founder of NARAL, former abortionist, and convert to Catholicism, has written about how important it was for NARAL to come up with a mediagenic term to describe the organization's mission. ''Pro-abortion'' was discussed and discarded, for example, as too vivid and confrontational. Finally, someone hit on ''pro-choice.'' Give credit where credit is due; adopting ''pro-choice'' was a brilliant advertising move. What is more American than having choices? Unfortunately, the pro-life movement has been on the media and marketing defensive ever since.
15 years 12 months ago
I think you answered your own question on who is "pro-abortion." Planned Parenthood. I am not sure that question was ever in doubt. There is a world of difference, however, in supporting Planned Parenthood's agenda and insisting that all abortionists be fined (pre-Roe) or jailed (the necessary consequence of a human life amendment or law).
15 years 11 months ago
The scenario: a college student does some old-fashioned, on the ground, investigative reporting that exposes how the employees of a major "reproductive health" institution are breaking laws. The result: a big, corporate media source decides to investigate the student and her "connections"...not follow-up on the conflict in the major reproductive health institution. Is this the sound of liberal media's death rattle?

The latest from america

Against the backdrop of deep differences with the Trump administration over migration and foreign aid as well as concerns for Ukraine and for Gaza, the Vatican secretary of state welcomed U.S. Vice President JD Vance to the Vatican.
Vance, who converted to Catholicism in 2019, attended the liturgy with his wife, Usha, a practicing Hindu, and his three children after meeting with Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni earlier in the day.
My Catholic identity and my wife’s Protestant identity continue to endure, and our faith has developed together in greater harmony, knowing that our love for each other was ultimately grounded in our love for God.
Damian WhitneyApril 17, 2025
the wily accuser tempted him in just the way to confuse a savior: All this I will give you.
Jerry HarpApril 17, 2025