Loading...
Loading...
Click here if you don’t see subscription options
Peter SchinellerJune 21, 2010

Every move of the Holy Father is examined. Thus recently when he prayed before the Shroud of Turin, many wondered if he would comment on its authenticity or lack of authenticity of the Shroud. As a matter of fact, he did not comment on the authenticity.

Now on the Fourth of July, he is making a second visit to  the Abruzzi region of Italy and will venerate the relics of St. Celestine V. The April 2009 earthquake devastated the region and the pope visited soon after. During that visit he not only venerated the remains of Celestine, but left there the pallium he received at the beginning of his pontificate.

Pope St. Celestine V was elected pope in 1294 after a two year conclave. He resigned after five months, was imprisoned by his successor and died 10 months later.

In accord with canon law, a pope can resign (Canon 333.2). No one expects Pope Benedict to offer his resignation at this tomb of a  pope who did resign. But a major problem still remains untouched by canon law. What happens if the pope becomes enfeebled or comatose, suffering from advanced Alzheimer’s and unable to carry out his office? 

A report in this magazine entitled “Power Vacuum?” of October 12, 2009 discussed this dilemma or gap, and the need for some regulation which would enable an enfeebled pope to be replaced. Such “special laws” have been promised (Canon 335) but have never been set forth. So perhaps this would be a good occasion for the Holy Father to set forth  the regulations or procedures on what would happen if a pope were to become comatose.

Peter Schineller, S.J.

 

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
James Lindsay
14 years 9 months ago
I read about Celestine in a church history book "The Cardinals." He is an inspiring and holy figure. I suspect that the issue of papal incapacitation need not come up. Unlike a President, the Pope has no divisions to command. His brother bishops can do nicely in a pinch. Additionally, given the prophesies of St. Malachy and the Secret of Fatima, after this pope - who is in excellent health, there is one more and he will be killed.

I suspect it is more likely that Benedict will lessen the scope of the papacy, create more western partriarchies and seek unification with Constantinople (rather than insisting the ancient churches unify with Rome). After doing that, the "head of state" nature of the papacy will be finished.

The latest from america

Pope Francis shared that he is experiencing “healing,” specifically “in my soul and my body,” as he reaches the eighth day of the minimum two-month period of rest and convalescence prescribed by his doctors.
Gerard O’ConnellMarch 30, 2025
With 38 years of experience in overseeing the process of canonization and beatification of saints, Monsignor Robert Sarno offers a deep dive into the world of Catholic relics, including their history, hierarchy and controversy.
JesuiticalMarch 28, 2025
Pope Francis continues to be in stable condition and has registered improvements in both breathing and speech, the Vatican said on March 28.
Gerard O’ConnellMarch 28, 2025
A large crowd gathers as Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum speaks during a rally at Zocalo Square in Mexico City March 9, 2025. (OSV News photo/Quetzalli Nicte-Ha, Reuters)
Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum’s deft handling of the mercurial U.S. president has sent her approval rating soaring, reaching 85 percent in the latest survey from the newspaper El Financiero.
David AgrenMarch 28, 2025