Loading...
Loading...
Click here if you don’t see subscription options
Barbara GreenSeptember 28, 2009

This Sunday’s readings all work to deepen for us a common conundrum, paradox or challenge: relationality—how any of us is related with everything else. The extraordinary reading from Genesis situates the original human as “alone” until it has named the animals and been configured into a male and a female. We can think of naming as an act of domination or proprietorship, as it sometimes is. Or we may see it as an action of intimacy, an acknowledgment and embrace of relationship: The human knows who the animals are and at least one of the emergent humans knows the other.  We may ponder the absent, unspoken words of the woman to the man and wonder why God calls the first human “alone” when God is present.  (The letter to the Hebrews struggles with a similar dynamic: How Jesus is both so like us and also so different.)  The patriarchal family emerges only after the man and woman eat the fruit in the garden and is characterized as consequent on that poor choice of theirs. That view of family is present in the psalm response to the first reading. It sounds serene, but—as with the Genesis reading—we might pause to ponder or preach on what is missing from the scene.

The Gospel challenges the patriarchal household and its imbalanced independence in several ways, I think. Jesus dethrones the male to some extent in a marriage, arguing for a greater mutuality than was customary. He re-values children (for those who read the “longer” version of the Gospel). And he asserts that God is thoroughly present with the humans in marriage: no “alone” here! God who joins humans, who helps relate one creature to another, is the ground of all our relating to each other. We are not the same as each other, not dominating, not owning or collapsed into each other. We are in deep co-creatural relationship, abetted and assisted by the creator of all.  

Barbara Green, O.P.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
15 years 6 months ago
More than dethroning the male, Jesus brings equality to the marriage and to the sexes generally.  Of course, some would rather proof text this verse as an attack on gay marriage.  It was not meant to be that and should not be read that way.  If anything, what Jesus and the Genesis writer say about the two becoming one flesh is a reason why gay marriage is essential, since there is no reason why heterosexual couples can be legally separated from their families and legally joined to their spouses while gay couples cannot be.

The latest from america

Against the backdrop of deep differences with the Trump administration over migration and foreign aid as well as concerns for Ukraine and for Gaza, the Vatican secretary of state welcomed U.S. Vice President JD Vance to the Vatican.
Vance, who converted to Catholicism in 2019, attended the liturgy with his wife, Usha, a practicing Hindu, and his three children after meeting with Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni earlier in the day.
My Catholic identity and my wife’s Protestant identity continue to endure, and our faith has developed together in greater harmony, knowing that our love for each other was ultimately grounded in our love for God.
Damian WhitneyApril 17, 2025
the wily accuser tempted him in just the way to confuse a savior: All this I will give you.
Jerry HarpApril 17, 2025