Pope Francis presided over the final rites in the funeral Mass for Cardinal Bernard Law, symbol of the Catholic Church's failure to protect children from sexual abuse.
The dean of the college of cardinals, Cardinal Angelo Sodano, celebrated Law's funeral Mass on Thursday behind the main altar of St. Peter's Basilica. Following the typical protocol, Francis presided over a final prayer, a blessing with incense and the sprinkling of holy water around Law's coffin.
U.S. Ambassador-designate Callista Gingrich and her husband, Newt, as well as some other members of the diplomatic corps were in attendance, along with the Vatican foreign minister, Archbishop Paul Gallagher.
Turnout was otherwise limited, with the basilica ushers stacking extra rows of empty seats before the Mass began.
One of the opening prayers read: "O God, who chose your servant Cardinal Bernard Law from among your priests and endowed him with pontifical dignity in the apostolic priesthood, grant, we pray, that he may also be admitted to their company forever."
Law, who died Wednesday at age 86, resigned as archbishop of Boston in 2002 after revelations that he covered up for dozens of priests who raped and sexually molested children, moving them to different parishes without telling parents or police.
The scandal, exposed by The Boston Globe and memorialized in the Oscar-winning film "Spotlight," then spread throughout the U.S. and world, with thousands of people from all continents coming forward in ensuing years with claims their priests sexually abused them when they were children.
The late cardinal’s successor, Cardinal Sean O’Malley, held a press conference on Wednesday at the Archdiocese of Boston’s headquarters. He expressed disappointment that Cardinal Law remained in such a high profile position following his resignation—and said he understands the anger some feel that Cardinal Law was afforded a funeral Mass inside Saint Peter’s Basilica, during which Pope Francis offered the final blessing.
Cardinal O’Malley, a member of the pope’s sex abuse prevention commission, said that he thinks “it's unfortunate that [Cardinal Law has] had such a high-profile place in the life of the church, but I think going forward that decision would not be made, but unfortunately we're living with the consequences of that.”
St. John Paul II's decision to promote Law to archpriest of a major Rome basilica in 2004 reinforced the impression that the Vatican still had not grasped the scale of the problem, the trauma it caused its victims, and the moral credibility it had lost as a result.
When pressed further if it was appropriate for Cardinal Law to have held a position of prominence in Rome—Pope John Paul II appointed him archpriest of a major Roman basilica in 2004—Cardinal O’Malley said, “I can’t imagine that happening today. I think there’s been enough growth and consciousness of this problem in the Holy See that that would not happen.”
Francis has inherited that legacy and has promised "zero tolerance" for abuse. But his own record has been criticized in some quarters, with critics pointing out that he has given the issue less urgency than his predecessor, Pope Benedict XVI. Just this week, Francis' commission of experts to advise the church on keeping children safe was allowed to lapse after its initial three-year mandate.
Cardinal Sodano was John Paul's powerful secretary of state at the time of Law's downfall and would have been instrumental in the decisions the Vatican took in those years to deal with the burgeoning scandal.
But the cardinal himself has a tainted legacy, having been a key supporter of the Rev. Marcial Maciel, the founder of the Legion of Christ religious order who sexually abused his seminarians and fathered three children. It was only after John Paul died and Sodano was sidelined that Benedict ordered Maciel to live a lifetime of "penance and prayer" for his crimes.
Cardinal Sodano, who presides over all funerals for Rome-based cardinals, said in his homily, "unfortunately, each one of us can sometimes lack in fidelity to our mission. That is why, at the beginning of every Mass, we say the 'Confiteor,'" the prayer that begins, "I confess to almighty God and to you, my brothers and sisters, that I have greatly sinned."
The pope read the prayers in Latin, sprinkled the cardinal's casket with holy water and blessed it with incense. But he made no remarks about the cardinal or his life.
This story includes reporting from Nicole Winfield at the Associated Press and Catholic News Service. This story will be updated.
Putting him to rest should have been less prominent and have attracted less attention than it did. No Saint Peter's and no cameras. Francis, at small event, in a monastery chapel and plot, close by where the Cardinal should have been spending his final years in prayer and penance, rather than at Santa Maria Maggiore would have been both more digniifed and fitting, and salutary for all involved. Pray for his soul.
Gee, and the Vatican wonders why nobody believes they give a fig about clergy sex abuse. Way to hold Law accountable (not).
no reason to get nasty! Unfortunately the Vatican had lots of time to prepare for this eventuality and to realize that the "normal" protocol simply would not do this time. Apart from Sodano, whom himself should have been sidelined a long time ago, not just for Maciel but his other nefarious accomplishments, the funeral and burial of Law should have been a quiet, dignified but uncelebrated event. This would have been the perfect day for the Pope to come down with the flu and he could have sent perhaps the local exorcist to do the final rites. Another opportunity missed and the message to the church is not clear.
A tone-deaf response to child abuse by priests in the United States.
The sex abuse scandal isn't the only issue with Cardinal Law. He was also the leading American prelate building support for the unjust attack on the people of Afghanistan in 2001. He was the leader in pushing through the resolution of the US Catholic Bishops meeting in I think November 2001 endorsing that invasion as just. So he has the blood of the Afghan innocent on his hands too.
Symbols are everything in the Catholic Church and the wafting of smoke around the coffin of Cardinal Law is one of them.
Pope Francis did what he constantly preaches, he provided a sense of mercy and forgiveness by his presence and his participation. That is the one Catholic faith attribute that so many Catholics seem to ignore. One need not presume that his presence was anything more than that because Francis' personal life demonstrates quite the opposite of what many people have said about him in this context. He seems to me the last one to be caught up in the imperial splendor of cardinals at the Vatican. Just look at where and how he chooses to live.
So Law went out the way he seemingly lived, caught up in his own importance. None of us will ever know whether or not he suffered any pangs of conscience. Ultimately that is between God and him. But Francis' presence at his funeral service should serve as a vivid reminder that we are called to be merciful and forgiving even to those who have done great harm. That is something of which I didn't read or hear much in all the reporting on Law's demise. A hard lesson but the ultimate Catholic one because each of us depend on the same from the Almighty through Christ's saving graces.
The whole Cardinal Law fiasco points to one overriding sad reality regarding the hierarchy of his era, that being the total disconnect between the clergy and the laity regarding the pedophile scandal.
The hierarchy appeared devoid of any empathy for the victims of pedophilia and their family members. If they had any empathy, it was overshadowed by a misguided desire to protect the public image of the Church, which was the height of hypocrisy.
This communicated two messages of significance to the laity. The first was that the image and needs of the clergy took priority over the safety and needs of the laity and second that the teaching about the role of priests as shepherds who protect their sheep and who are willing to die for them to do so, was heard as " a noisy gong and clanging symbol" due to a lack of any genuine compassion for the laity on the part of the hierarchy.